Old City Cigars

Casey Widner

4 months ago

★★★★★

I don't smoke cigars, but my husband does every once in a while. Graham was SUPER helpful and had great conversations with him. Prices were great and the place didn't stiff you. Totally recommended this place.

Edward O'Brien

4 months ago

★★★★★

Amazing variety of great leaf that you won’t find anywhere. Ivonne has a lot of knowledge and guides you through a world of great cigars all over the world.

Sarah

4 months ago

★

Graham is such a weirdo and honestly kind of a creep. The whole experience was super uncomfortable, and I wouldn’t recommend dealing with him at all. Seriously, just go anywhere else — save yourself the trouble. Update: The interaction I've had with Graham stalking my social media, my spouses social media, continually being an absolute creep and his boss backing up his insane actions. I had not spoken to him in probably about two years, he is not mentally well and women should stay away from this location.

Manuel Velazquez

a year ago

★★★★★

I visited all the shops around and Old City has the best Humidor on St George’s St by far. Graham is the man! He takes detailed notes of every cigar, his notebook blew me away when I saw it. I visited years ago and was glad to see he was still there. As a cigar shop owner myself I always tell my new employees about the cigar shopkeeper with the notebook I met in St Augustine. Will definately keep coming back when I visit!

Dave Payne

2 years ago

★★★★★

Awesome store with friendly service. The selection of cigars is extensive and superb! They also have a nice selection of high-end cigars. I definitely recommend shopping here for a stogie to enjoy in St. Augustine and to take home a few!