Casa de Montecristo by Cigar Inn - New York, NY (73rd St)

Persio Rodríguez

7 years ago

★★★★

Great place for a smoke. They have a well stocked walk in humidor with a descent variety of cigars. Prices are regular Manhattan prices. Ventilation could be better though.

Adam Munoz

9 years ago

★★★★

Wow staff was awesome and the cigar selection was good with fair prices. We brought some bourbon in and the waitress was quick to bring ice and glasses. Two large seating areas with plush couches and chairs. The crowd was of course on the older side, but that was nice change of pace. Will be back and definitely recommend.

Andrew Cohen

7 years ago

★★★★★

Fantastic cigar hideout on the upper east side. Super friendly staff along with a great humidor and very reasonable prices. Best part is BYOB while you enjoy a leisurely smoke. They provide the ice and glasses too. Plenty of comfy seating, several TVs and clean bathrooms. Bonus is that they’re open late. My living room away from home!

Ali Issaei

7 years ago

★★★★★

Nice and cozy place with great staff. I had a really good experience in this place. Ken is a great guy with very positive attitude. Keep up the good work!

Gary Koch

9 years ago

★★★★

This is my go-to cigar spot in the entire city. Always clean, friendly/helpful staff, ample comfortable space (arm chairs, couches, etc.), and the most important sports/political events are playing on their big screen TVs. Most importantly they have one of the best cigar selections in the city, at a very reasonable price. I docked them 1 star is because they don't always have the newest and greatest blends available, which can be frustrating when you wish to try a cigar before buying in bulk online, and occasionally you find cigars on the shelf with mold on them. Also the ventilation could be better, especially when it gets busy.